10-327/Homework Assignment 2: Difference between revisions

From Drorbn
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(5 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 11: Line 11:


===Suggestions for Good Deeds===
===Suggestions for Good Deeds===
Annotate our Monday videos (starting with {{10-327/vp|0927}}) in a manner similar to (say) {{dbnvp link|AKT-090910-1|AKT-090910-1}}, and/or add links to the blackboard shots, in a manner similar to {{dbnvp link|Alekseev-1006-1|Alekseev-1006-1}}. Also, make ''constructive'' suggestions to me, {{Dror}} and / or the videographer, Qian (Sindy) Li, on how to improve the videos and / or the software used to display them. Note that "constructive" means also, "something that can be implemented relatively easily in the real worlds, given limited resources".
Annotate our Monday videos (starting with {{10-327/vp|0927}}) in a manner similar to (say) {{dbnvp link|AKT-090910-1|AKT-090910-1}}, and/or add links to the blackboard shots, in a manner similar to {{dbnvp link|Alekseev-1006-1|Alekseev-1006-1}}. Also, make ''constructive'' suggestions to me, {{Dror}} and / or the videographer, Qian (Sindy) Li, on how to improve the videos and / or the software used to display them. Note that "constructive" means also, "something that can be implemented relatively easily in the real world, given limited resources".


{{Template:10-327:Dror/Students Divider}}
{{Template:10-327:Dror/Students Divider}}
Line 26: Line 26:
*** I found a way to approach this problem but I am not sure about the technicality. <math>X \times X</math> is Hausdorff. We take any point in <math>\Delta</math> complement. So we can separate it from any point in <math>\Delta</math>. But to separate it from the entire <math>\Delta</math> we need to get the intersection of all its open nbds. Will that still be a valid open nbd? -Kai [[User:Xwbdsb|Xwbdsb]] 11:29, 2 October 2010 (EDT)
*** I found a way to approach this problem but I am not sure about the technicality. <math>X \times X</math> is Hausdorff. We take any point in <math>\Delta</math> complement. So we can separate it from any point in <math>\Delta</math>. But to separate it from the entire <math>\Delta</math> we need to get the intersection of all its open nbds. Will that still be a valid open nbd? -Kai [[User:Xwbdsb|Xwbdsb]] 11:29, 2 October 2010 (EDT)
**** An arbitrary intersection of open sets is not necessarily open. This I'll say, but beyond this, it is your problem to solve. [[User:Drorbn|Drorbn]] 16:21, 2 October 2010 (EDT)
**** An arbitrary intersection of open sets is not necessarily open. This I'll say, but beyond this, it is your problem to solve. [[User:Drorbn|Drorbn]] 16:21, 2 October 2010 (EDT)

Solution

As promised, I provide my solution to HW2 here for any one of you might care. -Kai

Latest revision as of 21:43, 11 November 2010

Reading

Read sections 17 through 21 in Munkres' textbook (Topology, 2nd edition). Remember that reading math isn't like reading a novel! If you read a novel and miss a few details most likely you'll still understand the novel. But if you miss a few details in a math text, often you'll miss everything that follows. So reading math takes reading and rereading and rerereading and a lot of thought about what you've read. Also, preread sections 22 through 24, just to get a feel for the future.

Doing

Solve the following problems from Munkres' book, though submit only the underlined ones: Problems 6, 7, 8, 13, 14, 19abc, 19d, 21 on pages 101-102, and problems 7a, 7b, 8, 9ab, 9c, 13 on pages 111-112.

Due date

This assignment is due at the end of class on Thursday, October 7, 2010.

Suggestions for Good Deeds

Annotate our Monday videos (starting with Video: dbnvp Topology-100927) in a manner similar to (say) dbnvp AKT-090910-1, and/or add links to the blackboard shots, in a manner similar to dbnvp Alekseev-1006-1. Also, make constructive suggestions to me, Dror and / or the videographer, Qian (Sindy) Li, on how to improve the videos and / or the software used to display them. Note that "constructive" means also, "something that can be implemented relatively easily in the real world, given limited resources".

Dror's notes above / Student's notes below

Remark on the Due Date

  • Dear Professor Bar-Natan, October 5 seems like a Tuesday. Do you mean October 7, 2010? Thanks! Fzhao 23:42, 30 September 2010 (EDT)Frank
    • I stand corrected. Drorbn 06:33, 1 October 2010 (EDT)

Questions

  • Hi, I have a quick question. In the last question on the assignment that is being marked, what does it mean for one function to "uniquely determine" another. Sorry, I have just never heard that terminology before. - Jdw
    • It means that any two functions with the property stated in the question are actually the same. Drorbn 07:19, 2 October 2010 (EDT)
  • Xwbdsb 00:39, 2 October 2010 (EDT) I have a question about problem 13 on page 101. What does mean when is an element in ? Does the author mean the ordered pair ? And we assume that we put product topology on ? -Kai
    • Yes and yes. Drorbn 07:19, 2 October 2010 (EDT)
      • I found a way to approach this problem but I am not sure about the technicality. is Hausdorff. We take any point in complement. So we can separate it from any point in . But to separate it from the entire we need to get the intersection of all its open nbds. Will that still be a valid open nbd? -Kai Xwbdsb 11:29, 2 October 2010 (EDT)
        • An arbitrary intersection of open sets is not necessarily open. This I'll say, but beyond this, it is your problem to solve. Drorbn 16:21, 2 October 2010 (EDT)