14-240/Tutorial-October28: Difference between revisions

From Drorbn
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
 
(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
==Boris==
==Boris==


====Try to Avoid the Einstellung Effect====
====Be Efficient====


By this point in the course, we become good at solving systems of linear equations. However, we should not use this same
By this point in the course, we become good at solving systems of linear equations. However, we should not use this same old problem-solving strategy over and over if a more efficient one exists. Consider the following problems:

old problem-solving strategy over and over if a more efficient one exists. Consider the following problems:




Line 20: Line 18:


Yet there is a less time-consuming approach that relies on two observations:
Yet there is a less time-consuming approach that relies on two observations:
:(1) The dimension of <math>R^3</math> is <math>3</math> so the size of a basis is also <math>3</math>.

:(2) No linearly independent set can have more vectors than a generating set (by the Replacement Theorem).
::(1) The dimension of <math>R^3</math> is <math>3</math> so the size of a basis is also <math>3</math>.

::(2) No linearly independent set can have more vectors than a generating set (by the Replacement Theorem).

Since a basis is a generating set and the size of <math>S</math> is <math>4</math>, then the Replacement Theorem tells us that
Since a basis is a generating set and the size of <math>S</math> is <math>4</math>, then the Replacement Theorem tells us that
<math>S</math> cannot be linearly
<math>S</math> cannot be linearly independent. Hence, the problem can be solved without solving any linear equations.

independent. Hence, the problem can be solved without solving any linear equations.




Line 34: Line 27:
'''Q2''': Determine if the polynomials <math>x^3 - 2x ^2 + 1, 4x^2-x+3, 3x-2 </math> generate <math>P_3(R)</math>.
'''Q2''': Determine if the polynomials <math>x^3 - 2x ^2 + 1, 4x^2-x+3, 3x-2 </math> generate <math>P_3(R)</math>.


Once again, we can solve a linear linear equation but we do not have to. Observe:
Once again, we can solve a linear equation but we do not have to. Observe:
:(1) The dimension <math>P_3(R)</math> is <math>4</math> so the size of a basis is also <math>4</math>.

:(2) No generating set can have fewer vectors than a basis (by a Corollary to the Replacement Theorem).
::(1) The dimension <math>P_3(R)</math> is <math>4</math> so the size of a basis is also <math>4</math>.
Since there are only <math>3</math> polynomials, then the Corollary tells us that it cannot generate <math>P_3(R)</math>. Once again, we used a more efficient strategy.

::(2) No generating set can have fewer vectors than a basis (by a Corollary to the Replacement Theorem).

Since there are only <math>3</math> polynomials, then the Corollary tells us that it cannot generate <math>P_3(R)</math>. Once again, we used a

more efficient strategy to solve a problem.





====Extending a Linearly Independent Set to a Basis====
====Extending a Linearly Independent Set to a Basis====


'''Boris's tip (for concrete sets and vector spaces only)''':


'''Consider the following strategy only if you are working with concrete sets and vector spaces:'''

If a problem requires us to extend a linearly independent subset of a vector space to a basis, then the easiest approach is to

add vectors from the standard ordered basis. Here is an example:



Let <math>S = \{(-3, -6, 0), (0, 7, 0)\}</math> be a linearly independent subset of <math>R^3</math>. To extend <math>S</math> to a basis of <math>R^3</math>, add


If a problem requires us to extend a linearly independent set to a basis, then the easiest approach is to add vectors from the
vectors from <math>\{(1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)\}</math> without disturbing the linear independence of the set. The only question
standard ordered basis. Here is an example:


is which vectors should we add?


Let <math>S = \{(-3, -6, 0), (0, 7, 0)\}</math> be a linearly independent subset of <math>R^3</math>. To extend <math>S</math> to a basis, add vectors from <math>\{(1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)\}</math>. The only question is which vector(s) should we add?


We see that both vectors in <math>S</math> have a <math>0</math> as the third component so a safe choice is to add <math>(0, 0, 1)</math>. Since <math>R^3</math> has a


dimension of <math>3</math>, then <math>\{(-3, -6, 0), (0, 7, 0), (0, 0, 1)\}</math> is a basis of <math>R^3</math>.
We see that both vectors in <math>S</math> have a <math>0</math> as the third component so a safe choice is to add <math>(0, 0, 1)</math>. Since <math>R^3</math> has a dimension of <math>3</math>, then <math>\{(-3, -6, 0), (0, 7, 0), (0, 0, 1)\}</math> is a basis of <math>R^3</math>.


==Nikita==
==Nikita==

Latest revision as of 10:37, 29 November 2014

Boris

Be Efficient

By this point in the course, we become good at solving systems of linear equations. However, we should not use this same old problem-solving strategy over and over if a more efficient one exists. Consider the following problems:


Q1: Determine if is linearly independent in .

We can solve this linear equation to find the answer:


where .


Yet there is a less time-consuming approach that relies on two observations:

(1) The dimension of is so the size of a basis is also .
(2) No linearly independent set can have more vectors than a generating set (by the Replacement Theorem).

Since a basis is a generating set and the size of is , then the Replacement Theorem tells us that cannot be linearly independent. Hence, the problem can be solved without solving any linear equations.


Q2: Determine if the polynomials generate .

Once again, we can solve a linear equation but we do not have to. Observe:

(1) The dimension is so the size of a basis is also .
(2) No generating set can have fewer vectors than a basis (by a Corollary to the Replacement Theorem).

Since there are only polynomials, then the Corollary tells us that it cannot generate . Once again, we used a more efficient strategy.


Extending a Linearly Independent Set to a Basis

Boris's tip (for concrete sets and vector spaces only):


If a problem requires us to extend a linearly independent set to a basis, then the easiest approach is to add vectors from the standard ordered basis. Here is an example:


Let be a linearly independent subset of . To extend to a basis, add vectors from . The only question is which vector(s) should we add?


We see that both vectors in have a as the third component so a safe choice is to add . Since has a dimension of , then is a basis of .

Nikita