0708-1300/Class notes for Thursday, September 20

From Drorbn
Revision as of 18:31, 25 September 2007 by Drorbn (Talk | contribs)

Jump to: navigation, search
Announcements go here

Contents

Dror's Note

Come to my talk today at 4:30PM at the Fields Institute!

Class Notes

The notes below are by the students and for the students. Hopefully they are useful, but they come with no guarantee of any kind.

PDF file of the class notes typed up in latex can be located here

Tex version of the file is also avaliable here so that people can easily make changes and repost here if they wish.

Exercise

The solution(s) below are by the students and for the students. Hopefully they are useful, but they come with no guarantee of any kind.

Configurations of a Generalized Cockroach (not entirely rigourous)

Let C_n be the manifold of configurations of a "cockroach" with n legs:

0708-1300-cockroach-labelling.jpg

Q: What is C_n? In particular, what is C_6?

n=2: Consider C_2.

0708-1300-cockroach-C2.jpg

As in the picture, label the angles of the joints \theta_1 and \theta_2 and the distances from the body to the feet d_1 and d_2 respectively.

The value of \theta_i determines the value of d_i. So, given values (\theta_1, \theta_2), possible configurations are given by positions of the body, which must have distance d_i from the ith foot.

That is, the body must lie on the intersection of the two circles of radius d_i centred at the ith foot:

0708-1300-cockroach-twocircles.jpg


There are 0, 1, or 2 solutions for the body position. If we look only at the top body position, the pair (\theta_1, \theta_2) determines a unique configuration. So, we can plot the subset on \R^2_{(\theta_1,\theta_2)}:

0708-1300-cockroach-C2region.jpg

The boundary points are where the "top" solution is in fact the unique solution.

By symmetry, taking the bottom solution gives us a similar region, and since the boundaries are where the top and bottom solutions coincide (there is only one solution along the boundary), the entire manifold is given by gluing the boundaries together. This gives a sphere.

n=3: Configurations with 3 legs consist of a configuration with 2 legs plus the configuration of the third leg. The configuration of the first 2 legs fixes the position of the body - and thus, the distance d_3 from the third foot to the body.

For certain configurations of the first two legs, the body is too far from the third foot, so these are not found as part of configurations with three feet. When the distance from the body to the third foot equals the length of the third leg completely extended, this gives a unique configuration of the 3-legged cockroach. Any closer and there are two possible configurations, corresponding to the two ways that the third joint can bend.

Let R be the region in C_2 = S_2 where the distance to the third leg is close enough to give solutions. The boundary of R is a curve, consisting of all the points at which there is a unique solution:

0708-1300-cockroach-regionR.jpg

So the manifold C_3 is given by taking two copies of R and gluing their boundaries together. This gives a sphere.

n \geq 3: Likewise, given that C_n = S_2, it follows that C_{n+1} = S_2 also. In particular, C_6 = S_2.

Dror's Evaluation

The solution for n=2 seems right but hard to understand. For n=3 the solution is absolutely right. Unfortunately for n>3 the solution is wrong. (Why?)

--Drorbn 19:46, 24 September 2007 (EDT)


another solution for n<5

Here's a not-too-sketchy solution for n=3 and a sketch of how the same approach works for n=4. The strategy also works for a 2-legged roach but I really really can't do 5 or more. Perhaps someone else can help! Note that for n=4 we have a torus, not a sphere! p.s. Sorry if the image is upside-down or hard to get to, I am just learning how to deal with technology